Totally Cool The Frozen Farmer Santa's Cookies Ice Cream Recall

Why it was recalled

Possible contamination with Listeria monocytogenes

Product description

The Frozen Farmer Santa's Cookies Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich the Elf On the Shelf 4 fl oz UPC 850023398178. Individually wrapped in plastic, 4 sandwiches packaged in a cardboard box, 24 boxes per case.

Lot numbers, UPCs & expiration codes

All Best by Dates Between: 09/04/25 to 12/07/25 Plant Code: 24-65

Where it was sold

Distributed nationwide.

What to do if you have this product

Compare the brand, size, and lot/UPC codes on your package with the codes above.
If it matches, don't eat it. Return it to the store for a refund or throw it away.
Wash surfaces and containers that touched the product.
If you feel sick after eating it, contact your doctor. In an emergency call 911.

Recall details

Recall number: F-1557-2024
Classification: Class II
Status: Terminated
Recall initiated: Jun 13, 2024
FDA report date: Aug 7, 2024
Quantity: 26453 cases
Recall type: Voluntary: Firm initiated
Recalling firm: Totally Cool, Inc.

Original FDA data

Every field from FDA enforcement report F-1557-2024, exactly as published.

Show all FDA fields

City: Owings Mills
State: MD
Status: Terminated
Country: United States
Event ID: 94829
Address: 38 Gwynns Mill Ct
Code information: All Best by Dates Between: 09/04/25 to 12/07/25 Plant Code: 24-65
Postal code: 21117-3512
Report date: Aug 7, 2024
Product type: Food
Recall number: F-1557-2024
Classification: Class II
Recalling firm: Totally Cool, Inc.
Product quantity: 26453 cases
Termination date: Oct 8, 2024
Reason for recall: Possible contamination with Listeria monocytogenes
Voluntary / mandated: Voluntary: Firm initiated
Product description: The Frozen Farmer Santa's Cookies Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich the Elf On the Shelf 4 fl oz UPC 850023398178. Individually wrapped in plastic, 4 sandwiches packaged in a cardboard box, 24 boxes per case.
Distribution pattern: Distributed nationwide.
Recall initiation date: Jun 13, 2024
Initial firm notification: E-Mail
Center classification date: Aug 1, 2024

How we source this data

Source: U.S. Food and Drug Administration enforcement report F-1557-2024, published Aug 7, 2024. View the source record (openFDA) · FDA enforcement reports

Last checked against FDA data: Oct 2, 2026. Content last changed: Oct 2, 2026.

FindMyRecall is an independent service and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the FDA. This page simplifies the official record; the FDA or manufacturer notice is authoritative, so follow its instructions.